Taylor Report on Employment – where now?

sr-blog-12

We (OK, a few of us) were on tenterhooks waiting for the publication of the Taylor Report into employment practices in the UK, but will it make things clearer or further muddy the waters?

Uber, Deliveroo and Pimlico Plumbers have all been answering legal questions about the legitimacy of a business model that sees them, and other companies, claiming the people work for them are self-employed, so they don’t have to pay Employers’ National Insurance, pension, holidays, sick leave, etc., as their competitors do.  At the outset, Taylor commented that there were areas into which he wasn’t tasked to delve (tax & National Insurance, for example), so it hasn’t, perhaps, been the free and open review that had been called for by many.

There are, however, several aspects that are unlikely to go down well with factions of the Conservative government.  Speaking in May, Taylor said:

“As we encourage people to vote . . . to inform themselves of issues, to volunteer in their community, is it defensible to say that for eight or more hours a day they should accept being ignored, denied information, treated as mere cogs in a machine?”

That could easily be interpreted as a call to reverse moves by the Cameron Government to apply cumulative restrictions to the ability of trade unions to provide that voice.  It could also be that Theresa May’s surprise decision to announce in November:

“…we will shortly publish our plans to reform corporate governance, including … proposals to ensure the voice of employees is heard in the boardroom.” 

might actually come to fruition, though there has been precious little mention of the radical reforms of employment law mentioned in the run-up to the general election.

However, it also suggests that implementation of the Information and Consultation of Employees Regulations 2004 (ICER) hasn’t had the impact that it could and should have had.  Certainly, many trade union activists viewed ICER with suspicion, partly because merely informing and consulting can achieve relatively little without scope for negotiation. Similarly, some employers saw it as a way to prevent unions from getting access to their workplace.  However, those opinions have been changing over time, as demonstrated by the TUC’s “Democracy in the Workplace” report from 2014.  There is considerable evidence that employers that actively engage with their staff are more successful than those that don’t:

“Happy and productive people equals growth” (ACAS)

Many were calling for a simplification of the categories, preventing confusion over whether people are employees, workers or self-employed: instead, Taylor seems to be recommending that a further category is introduced, that of “Dependent Contractor”, something more than self-employed, clearly less than a worker, but that is presumably intended to level the playing field.

Quite how the Government will react to the findings is, frankly, anyone’s guess, especially with the level of distraction coming from Brexit, May’s increasingly slender majority, rumoured challenges for the Tory leadership (and, hence, the job of Prime Minister) and Labour apparently surging ahead of the Conservatives for the first time since the General Election, it’ll be a real surprise if they turn to this as a matter of urgency.  But it is the response of Government to these findings that will determine whether or not they make a positive difference for employers and those they employ.

Instead, attention will again be drawn to Uber’s fortunes in the Employment Appeals Tribunal in September.

From where I’m sitting, one answer is in the hands of every employer; improve your working relationship with your staff and, in turn, make the business more productive and more profitable.  That’s an area where I would certainly like to help.

I’d be interested to know your thoughts on the issues raised in this article, so please leave a comment or, if you’d like to discuss anything more directly, please contact us or give me a call on 07736068787.

READ ALL OUR NEWS


Strikes-Bill-UK-1

January 13, 2023

Strikes Bill UK: Striking the Right Legal Balance

Industrial actions over the past months have highlighted the difficulties for both organisations and individuals in the wake of the pandemic, energy and cost-of-living crisis.

Read More >

Lewis

October 27, 2022

Failures in Communication: Stormy Seas ahead for Workplace Relations

The latest events in British politics show us how damaging the results of failures in communication can be. 

Read More >

Boreray-yellow

July 1, 2022

Stormy Industrial Seas

I’m just back from the wonderful experience of visiting St Kilda. 

Read More >

Bass-Rock

February 23, 2022

Get Past No in Negotiations & Disputes

How a change in perspective can help with dispute resolution

Read More >

PXL_20210301_115243788-1-edited-scaled

March 10, 2021

"I’d rather struggle and complain!"

Have you ever found yourself dealing with someone who refuses to see a solution you find blindingly obvious, but refuses to take it? You’re not alone!

Read More >

DSC_0015-scaled

January 19, 2021

Are you listening?

One of the keys to successful negotiation is to listen and understand what’s REALLY being said by the ‘other side’. As a mediator and negotiator, listening is my stock in trade, but that doesn’t mean it happens easily.

Read More >

IMG_20200101_135012

November 24, 2020

Winning arguments with yourself?

I recently spoke with Roxanne Kerr of Helix Trauma Therapies for her regular podcast. We set out to discuss why conflict occurs. I enjoyed the conversation and I thought I’d share the result.

Read More >

I35012

October 12, 2020

International Mediation Training

Over the last couple of years, I’ve been privileged to deliver mediation skills training on a number of occasions for the ITCILO, writes Strathesk Re:solutions Founding Director, Malcolm Currie.

Read More >

DSCN0184-scaled

June 15, 2020

Legal mediation: time to start talking!

With court business still at a low ebb, there has never been a better time to consider mediation. Find out how online mediation works, where to access it and how you can try it out

Read More >

header-citypsychologygroup

April 28, 2020

A Day to Remember

Forget-me-not - this year International Workers’ Memorial Day has a special poignancy. 

Read More >

Edinburgh-skyline-scaled

March 30, 2020

Looking Beyond Lockdown

It’s the end of our first week in lockdown, so I thought I’d share my reflections on how I, and my business, are being affected.

Read More >

PANO_20190810_161239

February 28, 2020

Governing Change at Work

There has been a lot of discussion about corporate governance in recent years, even more about the place of the workforce within that. 

Read More >

White-fronted-kingfisher-Bharatpur

November 8, 2019

Taking Mediation to the Next Level

About a year ago, Founding Director of Strathesk Re:solutions, Malcolm Currie, undertook to take his mediation to the next level. Sounds good! But what on Earth does it mean?

Read More >

sr-blog-1

July 11, 2019

Lessons from staying in the middle

Malcolm Currie, a member of CEDR's Training Faculty shares his experience of being a Rugby Referee Coach and a Trade Union Negotiator and the lessons he has learnt from them.

Read More >

IMG-20190506-WA0006

May 23, 2019

Taking a Long Look at Yourself…

One of the disciplines that underpins mediation is the benefit that comes from reflecting on how a recent process has run. But it’s a habit that can have much wider benefits.

Read More >

IMG_20190410_192757

April 17, 2019

Reflections from Tbilisi

Read More >

sr-blog-3

January 31, 2019

To mediate, or not to mediate, that is the question

Despite that, many employers have been slow to adopt mediation as an approach, often reluctant to put it in place early enough to prevent some situations becoming intractable. 

Read More >

sr-blog-4

November 20, 2018

Bullying at work shouldn’t be hidden by ‘playground’ stigma

This is Anti-Bullying Week 2018 (#ABW2018), with a series of events, articles and publications aimed at making the problem of bullying something about which we all know more and are better equipped to stop.

Read More >

sr-blog-5

October 16, 2018

Putting Mental Health in its Proper Workplace…

Last Wednesday was World Mental Health Day 2018.  The day aims to raise awareness of mental health and the issues around it, particularly those that arise from mental ILL-health.

Read More >

sr-blog-6

July 17, 2018

A record year for strikes

The Office of National Statistics has recently published its latest figures around industrial disputes. 

Read More >

sr-blog-7

March 18, 2018

International Women’s Day – is it needed?

Today is International Women’s Day, so I thought it was timely to reflect on perceptions of women’s place in UK societyand ask the question: International Women’s Day – is it needed?

Read More >

sr-blog-8

February 13, 2018

Shared Parental Leave, Another Push?

The Government is running a campaign to encourage new parents to share their parental leave.

Read More >

sr-blog-9

December 14, 2017

Training in Copenhagen

At the end of November I delivered a training course on Advanced Negotiation Skills.

Read More >

sr-blog-10

October 6, 2017

SME Sickness Absence – Prevention or Cure, THAT is the Problem…

Most of my blogs have been about topics in the news that I find interesting, or on which I’d like to provoke a little debate, but this time round I thought I’d take a slightly different approach and reach out to people who.

Read More >

sr-blog-11

July 27, 2017

Good Riddance to Employment Tribunal Fees

Well, it’s been a long time coming, but the Cameron Government’s decision to charge fees for people to raise claims in the Employment Tribunal has finally been shown to be illegal.

Read More >

sr-blog-12

July 10, 2017

Taylor Report on Employment – where now?

We (OK, a few of us) were on tenterhooks waiting for the publication of the Taylor Report into employment practices in the UK, but will it make things clearer or further muddy the waters?

Read More >

sr-blog-13

May 19, 2017

Back to the Future as wages are predicted to stay in the past

In spite of political insistence that the economy is recovering, and has been for a good while, this week the BBC’s Economics Editor has predicted that wages are likely to stagnate for a good while longer.

Read More >

sr-blog-14

April 17, 2017

Trade Unions face big new fines

“The number of working days lost are at historically low levels when looking at the long-run monthly time series back to the 1930s.”

Read More >